A national conversation about Sureshbhai Patel and police brutality took place online last week when South Asian Americans Leading Together (SAALT) and 18 Million Rising hosted a Google hangout on March 22. The speakers involved also discussed connections between Patel’s case and the Movement for Black Lives and a broader call for police accountability.
While visiting Madison, Alabama, from India in February 2015, Sureshbhai Patel took a morning walk in his son’s neighborhood. The 57-year-old Patel was seriously injured after an encounter with police officers responding to a neighbor’s call about a “skinny black guy” walking suspiciously in the neighborhood. Officer Eric Parker slammed Patel to the ground, leaving him partially paralyzed. After a national outcry and public apology from the Alabama governor, Patel’s case resulted in two mistrials. In January 2016 a federal judge acquitted Parker in the civil rights suit against him, a case in which the defense attorney made an issue of Patel’s immigration status, lack of ID card on the walk, and English language abilities.
Suman Raghunathan of SAALT moderated last week’s discussion, which included an update from Chirag Patel on his father’s condition, an update on the case, and discussion of how South Asian families and communities can discuss police brutality and the Movement for Black Lives. Watch video of the event below, and check out some of the comments on Twitter from the speakers and others who joined the #Justice4MrPatel conversation.
Speakers included:
- Bhavani Kakani, president of Asha Kiran, founded to serve people of North Alabama in providing confidential, culturally sensitive assistance and services to South Asians and others that are experiencing “crisis” situations
- Deepa Iyer, senior fellow with the Center for Social Inclusion, a national policy strategy organization whose mission is to dismantle structural racism
- Purvi Shah, Bertha Justice Institute director with the Center for Constitutional Rights, a non-profit legal and educational organization committed to the creative use of law as a positive force for social change
- Fahd Ahmed, executive director of Desis Rising Up and Moving, an NYC multigenerational, membership led organization of low-wage South Asian immigrant workers and youth
- Sasha W., director of organizing with the National Queer Asian Pacific Islander Alliance (NQAPIA), a federation of LGBTQ Asian American, South Asian, Southeast Asian and Pacific Islander organizations
I am in tears as I live tweet for @18millionrising and listen to #Justice4MrPatel. Follow along.
— Taz (@TazzyStar) March 22, 2016
https://twitter.com/SAPrasanna/status/712358088226041856
We need to build capacity in places like Alabama to help groups deal with growing needs of South Asian communities #Justice4MrPatel
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
Moved by the tears of a son whose father will *never fully recover* frm police brutality. WatchNow https://t.co/ehMmxuIupF #Justice4MrPatel
— sushma sheth ray (@sushmachete) March 22, 2016
Two mistrials in Sureshbhai Patel case, demonstrating that in such cases, the legal system does not provide justice. #Justice4MrPatel
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
Powerful to learn about the critical training work Asha Kiran does in Alabama, linking police brutality to language access #Justice4MrPatel
— maanav (@maanavthakore) March 22, 2016
"While South Asians do not experience police brutality at same rate as others, we cannot stand on sideline." @dviyer #Justice4MrPatel
— 18MR (@18millionrising) March 22, 2016
"We are affected by system in different ways. We can't take or eyes away from the epidemic of police brutality." @dviyer #Justice4MrPatel
— Diane Wong (@XpertDemon) March 22, 2016
https://twitter.com/SAPrasanna/status/712360744675893248
At root of BLM movement, is a family's refusal to accept what was happening to their family members – Purvi Shah #Justice4MrPatel
— 18MR (@18millionrising) March 22, 2016
"Resistance to police brutality begins with people like Chirag-a person seeking justice for their family" @leftinmiami #Justice4MrPatel
— sushma sheth ray (@sushmachete) March 22, 2016
South Asians: build REAL relationships with Black communities & support Black led organizing. Our fates are linked. #Justice4MrPatel
— maanav (@maanavthakore) March 22, 2016
In NYC, Stop & Frisk has been a major issue in working class South Asian communities – Fahd Ahmed @DesisRisingUp #Justice4MrPatel
— maanav (@maanavthakore) March 22, 2016
Policing affects South Asians, particularly Muslims, says Fahd Ahmed of @DesisRisingUp, like harassment, surveillance #Justice4MrPatel
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
Fahd Ahmed, @DesisRisingUp: "South Asian youth stopped and frisked 40-60 times, hanging out w/Black youth stopped 80 times" #Justice4MrPatel
— Anirvan Chatterjee (@anirvan) March 22, 2016
"In NYC stop-and-frisk affects South Asian youth in Jamaica and Jackson Heights, Queens." -Fahd Ahmed at @DesisRisingUp #Justice4MrPatel
— Diane Wong (@XpertDemon) March 22, 2016
#Justice4MrPatel resources from nat'l hangout https://t.co/apt5DdDiaj @dviyer
— SAALT (@SAALTweets) March 22, 2016
#Justice4MrPatel more great resources from nat'l hangout on talking to our families https://t.co/CmcGpKUkBV
— SAALT (@SAALTweets) March 22, 2016
On why South Asians need to get with #BlackLivesMatter via @TheRoot https://t.co/8yNN7aaGLt #Justice4MrPatel
— Zeba Khan (@zebakhan) March 22, 2016
Let's "address our own antiblack racism and internalized oppression with policing" from SashaW @NQAPIA @APIresistance #Justice4MrPatel
— sushma sheth ray (@sushmachete) March 22, 2016
Often South Asians use their class privilege to disengage from movements for justice, says Sasha W from @NQAPIA #Justice4MrPatel @SAALTweets
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
https://twitter.com/taniappleseed/status/712366874474848256
Stay connected with @SAALTweets to learn about what happens next in civil lawsuit related to #Justice4MrPatel and how we can act
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
Action: REPORT when something wrong happens 2 U. This will help build the case before someone actually gets hurts -Chirag #Justice4MrPatel
— sushma sheth ray (@sushmachete) March 22, 2016
I would love to see more East Asians participating in the #Justice4MrPatel discussion because police violence and abuse affects us all
— Diane Wong (@XpertDemon) March 22, 2016
Chirag Patel: It's not just about safety for Limited English Proficiency folks—same issues apply to people with disabilies #Justice4MrPatel
— Anirvan Chatterjee (@anirvan) March 22, 2016
What was on trial in #Justice4MrPatel? IMO: not cop's conduct but Mr Patel's immigration status & English ability. https://t.co/gmopqvGZwx
— Deepa Iyer (@dviyer) March 22, 2016
#Justice4MrPatel "We cannot create a safe haven for anti-Black racism in any of our professions or institutions." @leftinmiami
— SAALT (@SAALTweets) March 22, 2016
Bhavani Aunty and other aunties are holding it up for us in the South – @dviyer #Justice4MrPatel
— sushma sheth ray (@sushmachete) March 22, 2016
It's not easy to do on the ground organizing in the South, respect to the Aunties of Asha Kiran organizing in Alabama for #Justice4MrPatel
— 18MR (@18millionrising) March 22, 2016
Chirag Patel: Excited to see folks across the country to support BLM, and vice versa. We need to invest for our children. #Justice4MrPatel
— Anirvan Chatterjee (@anirvan) March 22, 2016
#Justice4MrPatel Chirag Patel ends nat'l hangout on powerful note that so many come here for a better life for our children. We must fight.
— SAALT (@SAALTweets) March 22, 2016
@ChiragPat3l my thoughts and prayers continue to be with you and your family #Justice4MrPatel
— Zeba Khan (@zebakhan) March 23, 2016
* * *
Follow The Aerogram on Facebook. Find it on Twitter at @theaerogram.